Recent Gallup data reveals a stark reality – U.S. employee engagement has plummeted to its lowest level in a decade, with only 31% of employees engaged in 2024. Despite billions spent on leadership development, culture initiatives, and engagement programs, the numbers continue to decline. This raises a critical question: Are we focusing on the wrong things?

The Current Paradigm’s Failure

The traditional approach of prioritizing individual engagement and human-centric leadership has created an unsustainable cycle. Organizations invest heavily in leadership development and cultural initiatives, yet engagement continues to drop, particularly among younger workers and across key industries like finance, technology, and transportation. This decline has occurred despite – or perhaps because of – the intense focus on human elements and individual satisfaction.

To break this cycle, businesses must shift toward a systems-first approach that aligns with their long-term objectives. One of the critical steps to create a business roadmap is to move beyond individual engagement efforts and focus on designing structured processes that drive sustainable success. By implementing clear frameworks and measurable outcomes, organizations can ensure long-term stability and efficiency rather than relying on short-term engagement strategies.

The Systems-First Alternative

The Power of Process

My most successful clients exist to solve problems and create value for stakeholders. When we prioritize systems and processes over individual preferences, we create sustainable frameworks that drive consistent results. Well-designed organizational systems ensure effective cross-functional coordination, streamline operations, and optimize resource allocation. This systematic approach leads to:

• Clear accountability and performance measurement
• Streamlined decision-making processes
• Consistent quality delivery
• Scalable growth potential

Financial Impact of Systems Thinking

Organizations with robust systems and processes demonstrate higher profitability through operational efficiency by reducing waste and operational costs With all team members focused on what matters, they also see improved risk management that contributes to enhanced stakeholder value.

The Path Forward

Shift from Individual to Organizational Focus

Instead of constantly trying to optimize individual engagement and satisfaction, business leaders should:

• Design systems that serve the organization’s purpose
• Create processes that ensure consistent delivery
• Implement structures that transcend individual preferences
• Focus on measurable outcomes rather than sentiment

Measuring What Matters

Rather than obsessing over engagement scores, my most successful clients track business metrics in three main areas, all contributing to their overarching financial performance and wellness, including 1) process efficiency metrics, 2) Customer impact and satisfaction levels, and 3) Operational excellence measures

Data Visibility and Purpose Alignment

The Power of Visual Data

Every team member should have access to a real-time dashboard that clearly shows:

• How their role directly impacts organizational objectives
• Key performance indicators relevant to their function
• Progress toward departmental and organizational goals
• Direct correlation between their activities and stakeholder value

This transparency creates natural engagement through clear purpose alignment and visible impact, replacing artificial engagement initiatives with meaningful connection to organizational success.

The Leadership Imperative

Leaders must shift from being “people developers” to “systems architects.” This means creating robust organizational frameworks that enhance cross-functional collaboration. It involves implementing clear processes and procedures and establishing measurable performance standards so that every one of your team members knows what is expected of them 100% of the time. Leadership must focus on organizational outcomes over individual preferences with data transparency and accessibility.

Conclusion

The path to organizational greatness lies not in endless attempts to boost individual engagement, but in creating systems and processes that serve your organization’s purpose. When we build strong systems and provide clear visibility into how each role contributes to organizational success, engagement naturally follows as your people find satisfaction in being part of a well-functioning organization that consistently delivers value.

As a business team coach, I’ve seen firsthand how shifting the focus from individual engagement to systematic, process-driven approaches creates sustainable organizations that serve stakeholders effectively. The time has come to move beyond the cult of individual engagement and return to the fundamentals of business success—solving problems, optimizing processes, and delivering value at scale.

If you know business leaders who would benefit from this perspective on engagement, please forward this newsletter. It’s time to stop doubling down on what isn’t working.

Wishing you a wonderful day!
Cyndi
—
P.S. Want to make your highest contribution in your work and life? Click here for your complimentary Core Value Index™ assessment (8-min to complete, and 97.7% reliability).